I’ve written here
before about my image of life as a sort of people mover. Each of us has a spot in
the stream of humanity, and this conveyance moves us all along from birth to
death, while others move along behind us and—at least for now—in front of us.
I’ve talked about
this image in terms of the “rightness” of our inevitable demise: the time comes
when it’s our turn to rotate off the end of the people mover so that others can
fill in the spaces where we’ve been. It also helps me to get a grip on my response
to the range of folks I see in the “real world.” I’m sometimes honestly stunned and
perplexed by the fact that there are people of all ages in the world—and they just keep coming, filling up places where
I used to be. Newborn infants, wobbly toddlers, giggling preschoolers, and
boisterous grade schoolers keep rolling into the spaces at the very back of the
people mover. Ahead of them, painfully self-conscious adolescents and young
adults move toward the spaces designated for adults. I see these near-adults
and think (stunned again), “You’re just starting!” Between those youthful beginnings
and me now stand generations of adults—some of my peers are great-grandparents,
which I guess means there are at least three generations behind me, two of them
adult-like.
This vision of the
human family on a people mover has its wonderful side and its troubling side,
and I’ve been reminded of both in recent days. I'm most often aware of the upbeat part. Generally,
I feel quite fine about this state of affairs—good even. The whole thing has a
certain symmetry and some inherent fairness. And it frequently provides these
moments of dazzling hope. For instance, my partner and I just returned from the
annual conference of the American Psychological Association. It was in Hawaii, a
beautiful corner of the Earth, which provides an opportunity to insert a few
pictures to thank you for visiting my blog.
This conference,
like most, has two appeals for me: the conference content and the chance to
hang out with friends we rarely see. Both were happy reminders of the people
mover.
First, the content
part: At this conference, like at many recently, we encountered truly exciting
work being done by folks a couple of generations back on the people mover. LGBT psychology is still wet behind its academic ears, so it's very exciting to see young folks, relatively new to this professional life, doing truly creative and sophisticated work in this area. The folks
behind us in this particular lane of the people mover are stepping in, filling
up the space my generation is leaving open, and doing so with grace and aplomb.
I can turn around and see them there, enthusiastic, thoughtful, confident that
they have something new and important to say. And they clearly do.
The social events conveyed
the same message. The young people who hung around the munchies table at the
social and lined up at the buffet at the group dinner, eagerly talking about research,
politics, and social change between sips of wine and bites of fish tacos—these folks,
too, are in our rearview mirror on the people mover. The future is coming along
behind us, and it looks mighty good.
On the other hand,
the people mover sometimes troubles me with its insistent movement of some
folks into and others out of the mainstream, that section of the contraption
that gets all the attention, the generation that is seen, heard, and honored. Which
is to say, I’m sometimes bothered by the sense that the crowd behind me is
getting what seems like a disproportionately large share of the attention these days. The realization that my
cohort is being displaced isn’t always a happy one.
I understand that this shift is reasonable, given that the folks behind me are now the heart of
this humming, stumbling society. Clearly, part of my discomfort with this is pure
narcissism: What about me? Be that as
it may, I now understand the impulse of old people—an impulse I hated when I was
younger—to reclaim our more visible, central, “important” years by saying
things like “When I was your age …” or “I used to do that, too.” It doesn’t
seem so long ago that we were in the
prime years, when we were the
demographic the advertisers wanted to please, we were the ones magazines and TV shows and movies coddled and
portrayed, we were doing all the
exciting, adventurous things. “When I was your age …”
So, this less-than-delighted
perspective on the people mover was brought home for me by a recent New York Times article (which was
actually a blog). This article / blog post was really good; it was about doctors’ reluctance to allow patients to die, even when they
choose to end treatment, and even (this part is amazing!) when they are in
hospice care. As some of you know, I’m interested in end-of-life issues, so
this article caught my attention.
After I read it, I
went to the blog site, called “The New Old Age,” to see what else it held. I found it to be rich in
resources on aging, with lots of tools and links to organizations around the
web. But what caught my attention was the paragraph introducing the blog. I
quickly got that the blog is not for aging folks. It’s about us. The
intended audience is the adult children of folks who are getting old. It’s for people behind us on the people mover;
it’s about people (like me and my
peers) who are approaching our time to be rotating off the end. Here’s what I read:
Thanks to the
marvels of medical science, our parents are living longer than ever before.
Adults over age 80 are the fastest growing segment of the population; most will
spend years dependent on others for the most basic needs. That burden falls to
their baby boomer children. In The New Old Age, Paula Span and other contributors
explore this unprecedented intergenerational challenge.
Now, I think it’s
grand that people are thinking about this stuff. If I were trying to tend to my
aging (and, presumably, ailing … among the “most [who] will spend years
dependent on others for the most basic needs”) parents, I would be ever so happy to
find this resource. I’m very clear that the pervasive fantasy that living
longer inevitably means living healthily until our last day is just that: a fantasy. I understand that
longer life for many will mean a period of limited ability, heightened
dependence. And it’s clear that having family members and friends who can be
present and supportive for that is important. So I’m not questioning the value
of such information. If I were in that situation, I would likely welcome this
blog—including its introductory paragraph.
But I’m not. Tending
my parents, that is. I may not even be happy about finding this blog, although
I’ll need to look at it more before I decide that. I know for sure I’m not
happy about the feeling evoked by that introductory paragraph, the sense of
being the “other”—even being described using the dreaded word “burden.”
This is the less-than-joyful
side of the people mover. Gazing in the rearview mirror can bring great joy at
the swarm of good people coming along behind us. And it can bring great
distress at the easy displacement we experience as the end of the ride
approaches. As many have said before and better, it’s not the end that troubles
me here; it’s the process of getting there. In this case, it’s the feeling this
paragraph arouses of no longer mattering, except as a task for someone to
undertake. It’s the slide from being the center of the herd, its beating heart,
to being consigned to its edge, its “burden.”
The actual experience of those who are aging is
totally lost in this paragraph, buried beneath the struggle their younger caretakers
face, the "burden" they must bear. Yet aren't there two feeling people here, two inner lives.
Surely there’s a way to keep both stretches of the long river of humanity in focus. Surely
it’s possible for both to see themselves (and be seen by each other) as agents
in their lives—rather than one being the agent of all that happens and the
other the object of it all.
Perhaps it’s just
that each generation sees itself as central. The NYT blogger sees her generation as the agents, her parents’ as the
objects. I see it otherwise.
Seems like we
should talk.